15 Ways To Reboot Batman After The Dark Knight Rises
What should happen after Christopher Nolan walks away&hellܫip;
Ditch the origin
Pros: Ev𝓡eryone who buys a ticket to a Batman film already knows Ba🦂tman’s origin story.
In fact, it’s such a well-known part of pop culture that Tim Burton’s Batman 🧸 deliberately subverted it, with Burton opening his first film with a family lost in Gotham that first-🌠time viewers would have totally assumed to be the big-screen version of the Waynes, before going in a completely different direction.
Every rendition of Batman – from the comics, to the animated series, to two movie versions &ndꦡash; has covered the Dark Knight’s origin story, and Nolan’s version is arguably the best of all of them.
How ref🔜reshing would it be to go into a new Batman franchise and not have to sit through another shot of pearls hitting the concrete?
We could join our hero halfwᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚ𒀱ᩚᩚᩚay through his career, with all the ru🧔les and tropes we know so well already established.
And it would satisfy all the fanboys and fangirls c🥃urrently complaining that it’s too soon for a Spider-Man reboot. There’s only so many ways you can make an origin feel fresh – the further away from it you move, the more unhappy fans will be. The closer you stick to it, the more bored they’ll be.
Cons: We can’t think of many 𝔉for this one – except perhaps there’ll be some unhappy boyfriends / girlfriends ✨/ parents who have been dragged along to see the film without knowing Bats' back-story.
Sign up for the Total Film Newsletter
🎃Bringing all the latest movie news, features, and reviews to y𝔉our inbox
But hopefully there’ll be enough time between when the first trailer lands and the general release date to give these people comics / Blu-ray boxsets of Batman and Batman Begins or introduce them to the Internet.
Keep it grounded
Pros: Weirdly, the Batman films seem to have accidentally paralleled the comic-book evolution of the c🅠haracter.
First, the ‘40s-influenced Gotham noir of Burton’s Batman , to which he introduced ‘50s Golden Age elements in follow-up Batman Returns (most notably, Catwoman).
Next came the ‘60s Silver Age mania of Schumacher’s Batman Forever / Batman & Robin (characters introduced in the 𓄧far sillier Silver Age include Bat-Girl and Poison Ivy, with The Riddler making a return to the comics after a long absence).
Which takes us up to Nolan’s ‘70s and ‘80s influenced double of Batman Begins and The Dark Knight (the comic went darker and more crime-focused, Lucius Fox, Ras Al Ghul, Henri Ducard and Batman: Year One all appeared during these decades).
From what we’ve seen, The Dark Knight Rises contains several key elements of the ‘90s incarnation of the series – with Bane, Knightfall and possibly even the No Man’s Land story-arc all look set to be referenced.
Which means 🅺that, in the next instalment of the movie version of the myth𓆏os, we’re due a ‘00s take.
So forget returning to the lunacy of Schumacher’s era, the post- Rises reboot will be staying focuseไd on the real-world crime elements already established by Nolan’s universe, and building on them – bringing them closer to home.
Arcs up for grabs include Bruce Wayne: Murderer – which would work as a courtroom drama on the big screen, with Bruce framed for murder, and Batman having to prove his innocence – and the iconic Hush se𓆏ries (though possibly that would be best saved for later down t💮he line in the reboot franchise, considering the fact it involves so many of Batman’s rogues gallery).
Cons: By sticking so closely to Nolan’s methodology, future directors would have to suffer from being constantly 🐻compared to the auteur’s near-perfect vision. It would take a strong character to maintain their own voice in the din of fan-whinging.
Maintain real-world villains
Pros: Don’t worry, this feature isn’t ꦕgoing to be 15 pages of ‘Just copy Nolan’ we’ll be veering off that path sh🌜ortly.
But t🌜here’s another element 🥃of Christopher Nolan’s continuity that simply has to be maintained in order for the Batman reboot to succeed.
Forget seeing the big-screen debut of Clayface, or the gritty update of Mr Freeze – the next Bat-villain has to be as believable as Heath Ledger’s Joker, as convincing as Cillian Murphy&rsquo😼;s Scarecrow, or as retooled as Tom Hardy’s Bane.
Possibilities include new versions of Penguin (we’d still like to see our dream of Philip Seymour Hoffman wielding a machine-gun 💧🥂umbrella realised) and Riddler (though not as a Jigsaw-style sociopath, please) – but we’d prefer to see brand-new (to the silver screen) villains.
The Black Mask, Hugo Strange, even Killer Croc (though he’ll need to get his name from scarring, as opposed ✨to mutant atavism) have potential for a place in a realistic Batman universe.
And our favourite out of thatღ lot? Strange, for reasons we’vꦆe .
Batman’s best villains work as psychological metaphors (schizophrenia for Two-Face, psychopathy for Joker, obsessive-compulsive disorder for Riddler) with cl𝐆ose connections to Batman's own mania. Which means that grander the scale, the lesser the impact.
But whatever happens, if DC seeks to mimic the success of The Avengers b♛y pitching B💯atman against a universe-endangering alien threat, it would be a massive mistake.
Cons: Once again, the curse of follow🔯in🀅g Nolan rears its clown-painted face: how on earth do you compete with his ingenious takes on such classic creations?
Introduce Leslie Thompkins
Pros: Leslie Thompkins plays a sig🐟nificant rol🍒e in the history / character of Batman, but she’s yet to be brought before big screen audiences.
Thompkins has two subtly different origins – in one version of contin🐠uity, she was the care worker who first comforted young Bruce after his parents’ death (which Nolan retooled to be a young Commissioner Gordon, in one of his many elegant plot-shifts) in another, she helped raise Bruce, providing a maternal counterpoint to Alfred’s father figure presence.
In both versions, she shares Thomas Wayne’s philanthropic vision of G๊otham City – running a clinic for criminals and drug addicts, out of the notorious Crime Alley.
In the classic There Is No Hope In Crime Alley , we learn that Thompkins was inspired to open the clinic by bearing witness to the murder of Bruce Wayne’s parents; she wanted to ensurꦬe that such a tragedy would never take place again – going by slightly different methodology to Batman.
Because of this, Bat💧man visits Thompkins on the same nig⛄ht every year, to remind himself of what he’s fighting for.
If you haven’t read it, seek it out – it’s a beautiful comic. And one thꦬat could provide a key chara✃cter for any future Batman franchise.
One of the🦋 few criticisms of Nolan’s Batman films is he hasn’t created many strong female characters (Catwoman looks to be the exception that proves the rule), Leslie Thompkins would definitely solve that – s🐠he’s a tough old bird.
Leslie would also allow the person following in Nolan’s footstep💛s to hold-off on the introduction of a new Commissioner Gordon.
Just as it’s going to be difficult to introduce a new Joker following Heat🐠h Ledger’s stunning performance, it’s going to be very hard to imagine anyone other than Gary Oldman as Jim Gordon – he’s been stunning in a very underrated role.
Thompkins could perform a very similar narrative function – be📖ing Batman’s key crime contacꦉt in the reboot story structure.
Cons: Casting will be key for Leslie to work – and mai🍬nstream Hollywood isn’t exactly bursting with roles for pension-age actresses, which means 🦹there aren’t as many to choose from.
Still, Helen Mirren would be perfect, as would Maggie Sm🅠ith. Yep, despite the fact we want to avoid comparison with Oldman, we still want Thompkins to be played by a Brit. Some things are too perfect to change.
Make him a detective
Pros: It’s an absolutely key aspect of Batman&r🍬squo;s character; in the comics he defines himself as a detective, not a vigilante.
And whilst we saw glimpses of Batman’s clue-chasing skills in The Dark Knight – even if some🀅times they didn’t really make sense; what was that s💫hooting the bullets into the wall bit all about? – often it felt as though Batman was discovering events as they were happening, rather than using evidence to stay one-step ahead.
We want the next incarnation to be a full-blown police procedural, with Batman’s sleuthing skills being so comprehensive they make Sherlock Holmes look like Tonꦑy Stark.
In the ‘70s, Batman frequently solved side-cases that had nothing to do with the main story, seemingly for fun. They were often versions of the ‘a man’s been found hanging in a locked r𝓰oom with no chair, how did he die? (answer: he stoo🅘d a block of ice) brain-teasers, but it was the Dark Knight Detective’s path to the truth that provided entertainment for readers.
Old Bats💧 was definitely from the Holmes school of 'eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth' school of detection and it was fun to follow. It could be just as fun in the reboot.
Cons: It&rsq🔜uo;ll take a clever screenwriter to come up with puzzles that are satisfying to solve. They need to be tricky without being frustrating, and clever enough to ensure that th𓃲e audience doesn’t work out the answers before Bruce does.
Introduce humour
Pros: Despite the darkness, Batman's traditionally a pretty funny superhero comic, wi🍰th a nice line in gallows / sarcastic humour (ignoring the pun in the image above, that is).
Mostly, the jokes come from supporting players, with Alfred, Nightwing and Robin all being used to lighten the tension. But Batman's been known to tell a few jokes himself - something that's almost ent♕irely absent from Nolan's films.
Whilst some of The Dark Knight Rises ’ promotional m🍰aterial suggests that the Nolan brothers are stepping up the joke-count for the final installment, we don’t expect it to be a laugh-a-minute.
We&rsquꦉo;d like the reboot to introduce a few wry pay-off lines to the growls and threats.
Cons: It’ll be important to get the balance right; we don’t want to see Bats chuck out ♔one-𒐪liners as often as he throws Batarangs.
Open up the universe
Pros: Let’s face it, following the success of The Avengers , a Justice League movie is inevitable.
But we’d argue that, rather than jumping in at the deep end with an A🧸quaman movie, it’s essenti🌼al that DC get their Justice League version of Batman right first.
So it’s important that the Batman reboot, whilst remaining firmly in the real-world that Nolan’s created, starts to introduce the moreജ fantastical elements that are essential for a League movie to get off the ground.
This could be as throwaway as a newspaper he🐟adline announcing the arrival of the fastest man in the world, or a TV news report about the discovery of a new islandꦗ which scientists have named Themyscira. But the references do have to be in there.
The Batman reboot wiಌll work best as a gradual transition from Nolan’s world into the more fantasy-heavy landscape that the sequels and spin-offs will almost certainly have t📖o exist in.
Cons: This is going to be extremely difficult to get right – the Batman reboot has to successfully bridge the gap between The Dark Knight Rises and Green Lantern .
We wish whoever⛄ takes on the task the ꦦvery best of luck.
Include a Superman cameo
Pros: Alongside opening up the universe with a few well-placed Justice League references for the fans to pick up on, the Batman reboot simply has to include a decent-sized cameo for Supꦚerman.
It could be in an Avengers 🎃style end-credits sequence, or it could be mid-movie, but it has to happen – and it has to be more than just be a red and blue fl💝ash in the sky.
Superman is a fantastic character in the Bat-verse. He doesn’t appear often, but when he does he’s a brilliant counterpoint to Bruce’s brooding. He knows Batman better than anyone – some o𒅌f our favourite dialogue about Batman's true nature has come from a Superman speech bubble.
Basꦚically, Superman and Batman work together as a concept. He’s the best route in for a Justice League movie set-up.
It would work in one of two wa🌺ys: If Warner Brothers wanted to cover the first meetin꧅g of the big blue boy scout and the masked manhunter, then have Superman appear at the end of Batman’s film, threatening to take him down because he doesn’t like his methods.
Then, the Batman reboot sequel can be Batman Vs Superman , they’ll fight for 90 minutes or so, before realising at 💮the end that they’re on the same side, and that they should set up some sort of League Of Justice to ensure that this sort of thin🌊g never happens again.
Though we’d infinitely prefer the second option, which accepts that in this new universe, Batman and Superman already know each other. We want an end-credits sequence in which Superman floats down onto a roof while Batman moodily peers out over Gotham. Superman lands, and says: “Bruce, I need your h𝓰elp.” Cut to black, roll credits.
Cons: There’s a small – but very vocal - minority of fans who hate Superman as much as they do Robin, thinking such a decent, moral and brightly coloured charact🥃er has no place in Batman’s dark and gritty universe. These people are wrong, and must be ignored.
Reinvent the Batcave
Pros: We love Batman Begins and The Dark Knight , but they both completely failed at delivering the concept of the Batca▨ve.
There’s a chance we’ll get it in The Dark Knight Rises – all we need is a rebuilt Wayne Manor, a bit of restructuring work in the caves established in Begins , and The Dark Knight &🥂rsquo;s supercomputer to be moved underground, but that’s probably fairly unlikely.
But don’t get us wrong, we’re not after the ‘60s TV version of the cave, complete with a Batcomputer featuring Special Escaped Arch-criminal Bat-locator, but we also don’t want to see Bruce sitting in an open-plan sky-rise apartment full of windows, wearing his bat-suit and holding his cowl, in broad daylight (sorry The Dark Knight geeks).
Batman belongs underground, and a Bat-film isn’t com🌌plete without his cave.
We accept that we probably won’t get to see one with a giant penny and a life-size animatronic T-Rex anytime soon, but the cave is an essential element of the character and one that needs to appear fully foꦓrmed in the reboot.
Cons: We’re really hoping it’ll make an appearance in The Dark Knight Rises – and Bruce wilᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚ𒀱ᩚᩚᩚl have more than enough time to construct it in his eight years off – but if it doesn’t show up, there’🅰s probably a good reason Nolan’s stayed away from it. There is something inherently silly about the concept, but that doesn’t stop it from being awesome.
Put more stuff in the utility belt
Pros: One of the things we most respect about Nolan’s Batman fil🍸ms is the fact that, despite taking place is a gritty realistic world, Batman still walks around wearing a massive golden belt filled with ninja shuriken shaped like bats. We’re not being snarky, we genuinely love it.
That&rsquo💞;s Batman’s utility belt, and it’s potentially as silly as the Batcave, but equally as brilliant.
And we w🅷ant to see it used much more frequently in the Batman reboot. Again, we’re not asking for Bat-shark repellent pulled from the belt in the ’66 movie, but we do want it to be filled with all the great tools you can see in the image above.
It ties in wi🥂th our desire for the reboot to put more focus on Batman’s detective skills – the utility belt is essentially his CSI kit, with an infrared camera, fingerprint dusting kit, and lockpick tools amongst its coolest contents.
Cons: It is one of the areas of Batman lore people make fun of the most – and to be fair, it has contained some ridiculous stuff over the years – but as long as the screenwriters avoid t🐟he ‘solution to ev✤ery problem’ issue, we think it could work.
Sam Ashurst is a London-based film maker, journal♏ist, and podcast host. He's the director of Frankenstein's Creature, A Little More Fle🦄sh + A Little More Flesh 2, and co-hosts the Arrow Podcast. His words have appeared on HuffPost, MSN, The Independent, Yahoo, Cosmopolitan, and many more, as well as of course for us here at GamesRadar+.